Other very strong factors include groaning, trash talk, setting, realism, sexual aggressiveness, and evenly matched opponents. My criteria are that the video should include holds or moves that have stuck in my head, hot men in hot gear (or no gear at all), and dramatic combat (heel-vs-face, grudge match, punishment, domination, high stakes).
After I give my choices and rankings more thought, I’ll probably revise it. I’m making up this “top 20” list in kind of a hurry.